#Fudge Lite Version 1.0.3 http://www.fudgelite.com ##Core Rules ###Fudge ladder: * Superb * Great * Good * Fair * Mediocre * Poor * Terrible ###Definitions: Fudge die (or Fate die): a 6-sided die with two "+" sides, two "-" sides, and two blank sides. 4dF means 4 Fudge dice are rolled for a result from -4 to +4. Trait: anything that describes a character. Ranked trait: any trait that fits on the Fudge ladder (usually called attributes or skills). Unranked trait: any trait that doesn't fit on the Fudge ladder (gifts, faults, backstory, character description). Supernormal abilities: magic, psionics, superpowers, etc. ###Character creation: The GM starts with a base set of traits that's applicable to most settings and alters the list as appropriate. The GM then gives the PCs points to spend to purchase these traits, starting at Poor (0 points) and increasing 1 point for every additional level. The GM may choose any number of starting points, but I'd recommend starting at 35 (equivalent to Fudge on the Fly Character Creation). ####Base traits: Athletics Healing/Medicine Hit Points Melee Combat Persuasion Physical Awareness Ranged Combat Social Awareness Stealth Streetwise ####Additional traits for medieval fantasy settings: Cultural Knowledge (history, religion, customs, etc.) Dungeoneering (knowledge of dungeon environments) Languages\* Magic Magic Lore Magic Resistance Nature (plant and animal knowledge, foraging, handle animal, navigation, and tracking) Thievery (disable traps, open locks, pick pockets, and sleight of hand) ####Additional traits for sci-fi settings: Galactic Knowledge (planetary customs, history, xenobiology, etc.) Hacking\*\* Languages\* Psionics\* Psionic Lore\* Psionic Resistance\* Repair\*\* Starship Use (Piloting, Gunnery, Astrogation) ####Additional trait for pulp settings (lots of chase scenes, airplane piloting, and/or train/airship operation): Vehicles (knowledge, driving/piloting, repair, operation) \*Optional \*\*Depending on the setting, the GM may wish to combine Hacking and Repair into a single Technology skill. The GM is encouraged to add and remove traits as appropriate for the setting. For example, when running a pocket monster game I started with the base traits, removed Healing/medicine, added Technology (a combination of Computers and Mechanics) and Nature, and combined Melee Combat and Ranged Combat into just "Combat". No trait should be obviously more or less useful than any of the other traits. If the trait is too specific, or the setting won't naturally challenge that trait, you should alter it to be more broadly applicable or just remove it. Conversely, if the trait is too useful you should split it up into multiple traits. As an example I found myself calling for Perception rolls too often in my games, so I split it into Social Perception and Physical Perception. It's recommended that the GM split the traits Magic and Psionic into smaller categories to match whatever supernormal system the setting uses. (see "Example magic traits for a medieval fantasy setting") ###HP: Hit Points are treated like any other ranked trait. Terrible HP is 1 HP and each additional level increases the character's HP by 1 point. Armor can add up to 3 HP. 0 HP is unconscious or incapacitated. Most attacks do 1 damage. Optional: GMs may also give the PCs bonus hit points at character creation to keep them from being defeated too easily. ###Trait Checks: Start with a ranked trait. Roll 4dF and shift the trait up or down the Fudge ladder by the number of steps indicated. Compare the result to the GM-decided difficulty level (if unopposed) or to the opponent's relevant ranked trait plus an optional GM-decided modifier (if opposed). A tie or better means the roller succeeded. The GM decides if a player's failed roll means failure or success at a cost. When rolling for an untrained or undefined trait: any trait that everyone should have some skill at (fighting, climbing, basic math, etc.) defaults to Fair, while any trait that requires specialized knowledge and/or training (particle physics, helicopter piloting, etc.) defaults to Poor. If you don't own any Fudge dice you can roll 4d6 instead. Treat a die roll of 1 or 2 as a minus, 3 or 4 as a blank, and 5 or 6 as a plus. Thus, a roll of 1, 1, 2, 5 would be equivalent to [-][-][-][+], which adds up to -2. ###Bonuses and penalties: Sometimes a player will have bonuses and/or penalties that could affect their roll. +1 is a good bonus, +2 is a very good bonus, and +3 is a very rare, very large bonus. The same modifiers also apply to penalties. Only the single largest bonus and the single largest penalty apply to any given roll. ###Combat: The GM describes a threat and asks the PC, "what do you do?" A failed player roll, or a player ignoring an oncoming threat, means the GM can inflict damage or cause additional problems for the PC. There is no initiative; the GM shifts the spotlight between the different players as needed. Successful attacks reduce a character's hit points by one. An unmodified roll\* of +3 or +4 counts as a critical hit and inflicts an extra point of damage. Attacks that target an opponent's weakness may also inflict extra damage at the GM's discretion. \*the 4dF roll before applying it to the trait Optional rule: If a PC takes damage as the direct result of a failed combat roll, and the unmodified roll is -3 or -4, the PC takes an extra point of damage. ###Healing: Resting for several hours in unsafe territory (enemy territory, wilderness, dungeon) causes players to regain a number of hit points equal to half the player's max HP, rounded up. Resting overnight in safety and comfort heals full HP. Players gain 1 HP for each healing resource spent (e.g. potions, bandages, spell slots, mana, or simply time spent.) Healing rolls are only required in stressful situations. ###Magic: The ability to cast a specific type of magic is a ranked trait. The different types of magic and the breadth and limits of those types are up to the GM. The following spell difficulty guidelines are adapted from Daneel's Simpler Magic System for Mini Six (https://forum.rpg.net/showthread.php?531361-Mini-Six-Simpler-Magic-System) ####Poor, Mediocre: Short Range (touch) Short Duration (one action) Single Target (one creature/object) Cantrips/Orisons, See Auras, Speak Languages, Burning Touch ####Fair, Good: Medium Range (bowshot) Medium Duration (several actions) Medium Area (several people) Charm People, Mystic Armor, Heal Wounds, Fire Ball, Polymorph ####Great, Superb, Fair Superhuman: Long Range (sight) Long Duration (entire scene/encounter) Large Area (crowd) Resurrection, Group Teleport, Earthquake, Anti-magic Zone ####Good Superhuman, Great Superhuman, Superb Superhuman: Any Range, Duration, Area & Effect Wish, Miracle Increase the difficulty if the spell being cast meets more than one criterion of a spell of that level. Bad Things happen on a failed roll. Precisely what those Bad Things are depend on the difficulty of the roll and how badly the roll was failed. A few suggestions (with some inspiration from Dungeon World and the Dungeon World hack Wizard World): * The best the caster can get is a lesser, limited version. * The spell has an unexpected side effect. * The spellcaster draws unwanted attention or puts themselves in a difficult situation. * The spell requires the spellcaster's ongoing concentration. The caster takes an ongoing 1-point penalty to spellcasting as long as the spell is active. * The spell disturbs the fabric of reality as it is cast. The caster takes an ongoing 1-point penalty to all spellcasting until they rest and meditate for at least an hour. * Same as above, but the penalty applies to all rolls the spellcaster makes, not just spellcasting. * The spellcaster takes damage to at least one of their stat tracks (health, mana, corruption, sanity, etc.) or loses additional resources (spell slots, time, equipment, etc.) ###Character Advancement: Characters get 1-3 Experience Points (XP) per session. ####Raising a ranked trait: Terrible to Poor: 1 XP Poor to Mediocre: 1 XP Mediocre to Fair: 1 XP Fair to Good: 2 XP Good to Great: 4 XP Great to Superb: 8 XP Superb to Legendary: 16 XP + GM permission For slower character advancement increase the costs. ##Example magic traits for a medieval fantasy setting * Abjuration * Conjuration * Healing * Illusion * Summoning * Transmutation ###Abjuration: Protection from an energy type or from physical attacks, cancelling magics, warding an area to prevent entry from anything fitting a certain criteria, warding an area to weaken any intruders that fit a certain criteria, banishing summoned entities, reflecting spells back at their caster. ###Conjuration: Lightning, flame, light, shadow, fog, acid, ice, stone, metal, wood, force, wind, grease, thorns, web. The qualities of the conjured material may only be manipulated as it's being conjured (e.g. to impart shape and speed to a fireball). If Conjuration is too broad a category it can be split into Mundus Conjuration and Aether Conjuration. Mundus is used for solid conjurations like earth, stone, metal, plant, and liquids like water and oil. Aether is used for gasses and energies like wind, fog, light, shadow, fire, lightning, and mana. ###Healing: Cure wounds, neutralize poison, regenerate, cure blindness/deafness/paralysis, cure disease, restore ability, resurrection ###Illusion: Make something/someone look like something/someone else, create phantom images/noises, invisibility. ###Transmutation: Changing a target's shape and/or size, changing materials, adding or removing qualities or abilities, animating the inanimate, enhancing or diminishing qualities. ###Summoning: Summon any of the following: monster, spirit, fey, elemental, animal, demon, undead, construct, extraplanar entity, swarm. The summons may be controlled or let loose, but an uncontrollable summon is much easier to summon. ##Game Mastering ###Sneak attacks and Coup de Grace: Hit points only apply to NPCs in situations where the NPC is able to respond to the threat. If the NPC is disabled or caught unaware, they can be knocked out or killed by a PC regardless of their hit points. A tough NPC or a heavily-armored one may be treated as having a passive defense trait, but it should be lower than their threat rating would be. ###Environment Hazards: Damage that could kill a human does 1 damage. Damage that could kill a horse does 2 damage, and damage that could kill an ogre or destroy a vehicle does 4 damage. ###NPC Creation: NPCs have a threat rating, hit points, and any other traits the GM wants them to have. Any undefined ranked trait defaults to the NPC's threat rating. NPCs also have behaviors that can be triggered whenever a player fails a roll, looks to the GM to see what happens, or ignores a threat. Enemies meant for short battles should only have 1 or 2 Hit Points each, while boss monsters should have HP equivalent to a PC (or more!) ###Example NPCs: ####Troll Threat rating: Great Gift: Quick regeneration. On a failed player roll the troll may regain a hit point. -and/or- Gift: Slow regeneration: The troll comes back to life a certain amount of time after dying (minutes, hours, days), eventually coming back to full health. Limbs regenerate, etc. Fault: Pretty dumb. Fault: Fire attacks and acid attacks both permanently take hit points off of the troll. Fault (optional): Permanently turns to stone in sunlight. Behavior: Big. Dumb. Strong. Grab things, pick them up, and smash them against other things. Do the same thing to people. ####Giant Spider Threat rating: Fair Gift: Paralyzing venom in fangs Gift: Webspinning Behavior: Create sticky webs to catch prey, inject a paralytic venom with your fangs, then wrap your prey in a coccoon before sucking their fluids out. ####Brigand Threat rating: Mediocre Behavior: Loot, pillage, and plunder. Obey your leader. Attack the innocent. Take by force. ####Brigand Leader Threat rating: Good Behavior: Command your followers. Reward obedience. Crush any challenges to your authority. Boast recklessly. ####Pyromaniac Fire Mage Threat rating: Good Gift: Spellcasting. Spells known: Fireball, Flamethrower. Gift: Immunity to his own flames. -OR- Gift: Immunity to all flames Behavior: Burn all the things! If anybody tries to stop you, burn them as well! ####Psionic Monk Threat rating: Superb Gift: Psionicist. Psionic abilities: Telepathy/empathy, Telekinesis, Physical Augmentation (acrobatic jumps, fast movement), Suggestion. Gift: Plasma Sword Behavior: Defend the weak. Destroy the wicked. Be at peace in all your actions. ####Fallen Psionic Monk Threat rating: Superb Gift: Psionicist. Psionic abilities: Telepathy/empathy, Telekinesis, Physical Augmentation (acrobatic jumps, fast movement), Lightning. Gift: Plasma Sword Behavior: Let your anger and hatred flow through you. Crush your enemies. Show no mercy. ####Mooks (guards, stormtroopers, minions, cultists, etc.) Threat Rating: Mediocre Behavior: Mob the heroes, die in droves. ###Example combat GM: The cultist waves his staff ominously over the altar, but the more immediate threat are his two warg rider cronies who are rapidly approaching you. The goblins have wicked curved blades and they cry for your blood. How do you react to their charge? PC: I cast a Flash cantrip to blind the first rider. GM: What's your Spellcasting skill? PC: Mediocre. GM: I'm gonna say casting Flash in this context requires a Mediocre magic skill, so you just need to roll 0 or higher on the Fudge dice. PC: \*rolls 4dF\* PC: Ouch. -1. GM: Poor result. The spell backfires and goes off in your face, temporarily blinding you. What do you do? PC: Okay, I know the wargs are coming, so I try to jump out of the way. GM: Athletics check. PC: Mediocre plus roll equals- PC: \*rolls 4dF\* PC: Augh! -3! \*GM laughs\* PC: That's... one level below Terrible! I did so poorly on my roll that there isn't even a ranking for it! GM: Blinded, you run straight into the wall. Using your moment of disorientation, the goblins attack you from warg-back with their swords. You feel the blades slice through your armor. Mark off a hit point. PC: That brings me down to 3 HP. Freaking hell. GM: Okay, the temporary blindness has worn off, but you're still a little disoriented. You're at -1 to your next roll. The warg-riders come around for another pass. What do you do? PC: I vault onto the nearest warg to knock the goblin off his perch. GM: That'll require a Good Dexterity roll, followed by an opposed Strength check to knock the goblin off. PC: \*rolls\* PC: Crap, -1. GM: Combined with the disorientation -1 and your Mediocre dexterity, you did Terribly. You make it onto the warg, but at a cost. Because of your fumbling the goblin gets a free shot at you. The goblin does one more point of damage. Okay, now for the opposed Strength check. The goblin has Mediocre Strength. PC: I have Good Strength, so this should work. \*rolls 4dF\* PC: -1, so my Fair beats the goblin's Mediocre. GM: And down the goblin goes! ###"Yes, but": For boring-but-necessary PC actions the GM may allow the player to automatically succeed with complications (or without complications if the action is trivial) as long as the PC has the appropriate trait at an acceptable level. This is an expansion of the "Tell the requirements and ask" GM move (see Appendix A: Dungeon World GM Moves). The player states what their character wants to achieve and the GM chooses up to four complications. The GM must tell the player the complications before the PC takes action. Situations where "Yes, but" would be appropriate include: crafting equipment, giving medical treatment, creating a new magical spell or effect, developing skills. ####Sample complications: * It's going to take days/weeks/months * First you must ____ * You'll need help from ____ * It will require a lot of money * The best you can do is a lesser version, unreliable and limited * You and your allies will risk danger from ____ * You'll draw unwanted attention from ____ * You'll have to take apart/disenchant ____ to do it * The finished product will have the following side-effect(s): ____ The GM may allow the player to choose between different combinations of complications. ("Either it will take a lot of money and several weeks, or you can swallow your pride and ask Jorgen for help." "Never!") ###Trans-Superb traits Unless playing in a superhero campaign, player characters don't start the game with skills above Superb. Still, sometimes a character's roll or a monster's trait goes above Superb. For these situations there's the trans-superb scale. Superhuman is a qualifier that adds +4 to a trait. Beyond Superhuman is Planetary (+8) and Cosmic (+12), but at that point you're talking about galaxy-ending threats. * Superb Superhuman * Great Superhuman * Good Superhuman * Fair Superhuman * Superb * Great * Good * Fair * Mediocre * Poor * Terrible ##Alternate Character Creation Rules ###Subjective Character creation: Write down everything important about your character, ranking any traits that can be ranked on the Fudge Ladder. ###Quick Character Creation (Over the Edge): Characters get a broad trait (class, occupation, etc.) and two narrower traits (specific skills). Any one of the three traits may be Great, while the other two are Good. Any supernormal ability must be the broad trait. The GM may also require each PC to have a fault. ###Quick Character Creation (Wushu): Characters are defined by 3 player-defined traits. One should describe their motivation and be ranked Superb, one should describe their fighting style and be ranked Great, and one should describe their profession and be ranked Good. The GM may also require each PC to have a fault. ###Fudge On The Fly Character Creation: Players don't have to decide on their traits before play starts. When a relevant trait is called for the player can fill it in in the appropriate spot below. The player may decide on a trait at any time. A player can only place a trait where there is an open slot for it. A player may create more Poor slots if necessary. Superb: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] Great: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] Good: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] Fair: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] Mediocre: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] Poor: [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] [\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_\_] ##Alternate Character Advancement Rules: ###Keys Starting characters get at least one free defined action of easy to moderate difficulty ("key") and the ability to buy more. Players gain 1 XP when their character takes the action ("hits the key") or 2 when the character hits the key against great odds or goes into danger because of it. Character advancement costs are multiplied by 10. Example Key: Key of Bloodlust: Hit your key when you overcome an opponent in battle. Players may buy off their key by acting in opposition to it, and earn 10 XP thereby. A key that is bought off can never be taken again by that character. A player may act in opposition to their key and still keep it; the player only loses the key when they wish to. Buyoff for the Key of Bloodlust: Pass up an opportunity for a good fight. Players may purchase keys at any time. Buying a key costs 10 XP, the same amount a character gets for buying off their old key. Each player can only have a maximum of five keys at any time. ###In-character Costs Players can improve traits, but there will be in-character costs decided by the GM (see "yes, but"). This may or may not be used in conjunction with XP rules. ###Learning From Failure Players gain 1 XP whenever their character fails a trait check. The GM should increase character advancement costs to compensate. ###Learning From Success Players gain 1 XP whenever their character succeeds a trait check. The GM should increase character advancement costs to compensate. ###Learning From Failure AND Success: Players gain 1 XP whenever their character succeeds a trait check AND whenever their character fails a trait check. The GM should DEFINITELY increase character advancement costs to compensate. ##Optional Rules: ###Fudge Points: PCs start the game with 1-5 Fudge Points. Spending a Fudge Point lets you do one of the following: * Automatically succeed at any unopposed roll of Superb or lower difficulty. * Alter a roll by 1. * Regain 1 HP. * Get a +4 result without rolling.\* * Narrate a detail of the world around them.\* \*This option requires the GM's approval and may cost more than one Fudge Point. The GM should award an extra Fudge Point whenever a PC does something awesome. Players start with full Fudge Points at the beginning of each session. ###Fudge Points for XP: Players gain Fudge Points (or fractional Fudge Points, several of which are equal to one Fudge Point) instead of XP whenever they do something that would normally get them XP. Fudge Points may be spent at any time for the usual bonus, but once the Fudge Point is spent it's immediately converted to XP that the player can spend. ###Wound Penalties / Simplified Wound Tracks: Whenever a character has taken enough damage they take a penalty to any relevant rolls. A character brought down to 2 HP will have a -1 penalty and a character brought down to 1 HP will have a -2 penalty. A character at full health never takes wound penalties, even if their full health is only 1 or 2 HP. A character with Superb Hit Points (7 HP) could record their injuries like this: Scratch: O O O O Hurt (-1): O Very Hurt (-2): O Incapacitated: O ###Simple Mana Points: Each spellcaster has a spellcasting attribute (e.g. mana, magic, soul, spirit). The rating of that attribute on the Fudge ladder determines the spellcaster's Mana Points (MP). Terrible mana is 1 MP and each additional trait level increases the character's MP by 1 point. Casting a spell costs 1 MP. Mana regenerates to full with a full night's rest. ###Stat Tracks: Stat Tracks can be used in addition to a health track whenever a character has to keep track of some sort of resource that, when completely lost, makes the PC unable to act or unable to act in a certain way. The default difficulty for Stat checks is Fair unless another difficulty level makes more sense. Penalties from different tracks don't stack; only the highest penalty applies to a character's actions. ####Health track (default) Penalty applies to: Physical actions Lose health when: taking damage Saving Throw: any appropriate combat or evasion trait Regaining health: Resting for several hours in unsafe territory (enemy territory, wilderness, dungeon) heals half the players' max HP, rounded up. Resting overnight in safety and comfort heals full HP. Stat levels: Scratch (0), Hurt (-1), Very Hurt (-2), Incapacitated ####Calling on dark forces Benefits: Allows the character access to dark magic spells and reduces the difficulty of certain actions (free Fudge point?) Penalty applies to: using light or neutral spells Stat Track based on: Willpower When to roll: Whenever a PC uses magic in anger or uses a dark magic ability. Trait to roll against: Willpower Getting rid of dark magic points: 1 point every 2 sessions. Requires in-character effort. Stat levels: Touched (-0), Tainted (-1), Corrupted (-2), Consumed (NPC) ####Sanity Meter (Call of Cthulhu style) Penalty applies to: Sanity, most social skills, and possibly Willpower rolls Stat Track based on: Sanity When to roll: Whenever a character sees something that Should Not Exist, excessive gore, or attempts to cast a spell themselves. Trait to roll against: Sanity Regaining sanity: 1 point per session, or 2 if the character undergoes therapy between sessions. Stat levels: Disoriented (0), Disturbed (-1), Unhinged (-2), Completely Insane (NPC) ####Mana Pool Benefit: allows the character to cast spells Penalty applies to: spellcasting and/or physical actions Stat based on: Mana Pool A failed spellcasting roll costs the character a point of mana. Alternatively, the GM may instead make an appropriate GM move. Note: If using this track, it's probably a good idea for the trait that represents a character's spellcasting ability to be separate from the one that represents their mana pool. ###Morale Checks: Each group of combatant NPCs has a Morale trait ranked on the Fudge ladder. By default this is the same as the NPCs' Threat Rating but it could be different. Morale is generally checked in critical combat situations. Two recommended times for morale checks are: * After the side's first death in combat. * When half the NPCs have been incapacitated. A morale check has a default difficulty of Fair, though this may be adjusted to account for the circumstances. Morale is checked for the entire group at the same time, not individually for each NPC. If the NPCs succeed at the morale check they will continue to fight. If they fail they will try to retreat. NPC groups that successfully check morale twice will fight to the death. ##Appendix A: Dungeon World GM Moves ###Moves Whenever everyone looks to you (the GM) to see what happens, choose one of these. Each move is something that occurs in the fiction of the game. They aren't code words or special terms. "Use up their resources" literally means to expend the resources of the characters, for example. * Use a monster, danger, or location move * Reveal an unwelcome truth * Show signs of an approaching threat * Deal damage * Use up their resources * Turn their move back on them * Separate them * Give an opportunity that fits a class' abilities * Show a downside to their class, race, or equipment * Offer an opportunity, with or without cost * Put someone in a spot * Tell them the requirements or consequences and ask Never speak the name of your move. Make it a real thing that happens to them: "As you dodge the hulking ogre's club, you slip and land hard. Your sword goes sliding away into the darkness. You think you saw where it went but the ogre is lumbering your way. What do you do?" No matter what move you make, always follow up with "What do you do?" Your moves are a way of filling the characters' lives with adventure. When a spell goes wild or the floor drops out from under them adventurers react or suffer the consequences of inaction. ###When to Make a Move You make a move: * When everyone looks to you to find out what happens * When a player gives you a golden opportunity (usually by ignoring or overlooking a threat) * When a player fails a skill roll Generally when the players are just looking at you to find out what happens you make a soft move, otherwise you make a hard move. A soft move is one without immediate, irrevocable consequences. That usually means it's something not all that bad, like revealing that there's more treasure if they can just find a way past the golem (offer an opportunity with cost). It can also mean that it's something bad, but they have time to avoid it, like having the goblin archers loose their arrows (show signs of an approaching threat) with a chance for them to dodge out of danger. A soft move ignored becomes a golden opportunity for a hard move. If the players do nothing about the hail of arrows flying towards them it's a golden opportunity to use the deal damage move. Hard moves, on the other hand, have immediate consequences. Dealing damage is almost always a hard move, since it means a loss of HP that won't be recovered without some action from the players. When you have a chance to make a hard move you can opt for a soft one instead if it better fits the situation. Sometimes things just work out for the best. ###Choosing a Move To choose a move, start by looking at the obvious consequences of the action that triggered it. Let your moves snowball. Build on the success or failure of the characters' moves and on your own previous moves. If your first instinct is that this won't hurt them now, but it'll come back to bite them later, great! Make a note of and reveal it when the time is right. ###Making your Move Never speak the name of your move and address the characters, not the players. Your moves are not mechanical actions happening around the table. They are concrete events happening to the characters in the fictional world you are describing. Note that "deal damage" is a move, but other moves may include damage as well. When an ogre flings you against a wall you take damage as surely as if he had smashed you with his fists. After every move you make, always ask "What do you do?" ###GM Moves: ####Use a monster, danger, or location move Every monster in an adventure has moves associated with it, as do many locations. A monster or location move is just a description of what that location or monster does, maybe "hurl someone away" or "bridge the planes." If a player move (like hack and slash) says that a monster gets to make an attack, make an aggressive move with that monster. The overarching dangers of the adventure also have moves associated with them. Use these moves to bring that danger into play, which may mean more monsters. ####Reveal an unwelcome truth An unwelcome truth is a fact the players wish wasn't true: that the room's been trapped, maybe, or that the helpful goblin is actually a spy. Reveal to the players just how much trouble they're in. ####Show signs of an approaching threat This is one of your most versatile moves. "Threat" means anything bad that's on the way. With this move, you just show them that something's going to happen unless they do something about it. ####Deal damage When you deal damage, choose one source of damage that's fictionally threatening a character and apply it. In combat with a lizard man? It stabs you. Triggered a trap? Rocks fall on you. The amount of damage is decided by the source. In some cases, this move might involve trading damage both ways, with the character also dealing damage. Most damage is based on a die roll. When a player takes damage, tell them what to roll. You never need to touch the dice. If the player is too cowardly to find out their own fate, they can ask another player to roll for them. ####Use up their resources Surviving in a dungeon, or anywhere dangerous, often comes down to supplies. With this move, something happens to use up some resource: weapons, armor, healing, ongoing spells. You don't always have to use it up permanently. A sword might just be flung to the other side of the room, not shattered. ####Turn Their Move Back On Them Think about the benefits a move might grant a character and turn them around in a negative way. Alternately, grant the same advantage to someone who has it out for the characters. If Ivy has learned of Duke Horst's men approaching from the east, maybe a scout has spotted her, too. ####Separate Them There are few things worse than being in the middle of a raging battle with blood-thirsty owlbears on all sides. One of those things is being in the middle of that battle with no one at your back. Separating the characters can mean anything from being pushed apart in the heat of battle to being teleported to the far end of the dungeon. Whatever way it occurs, it's bound to cause problems. ####Give an opportunity that fits a class' abilities The thief disables traps, sneaks, and picks locks. The cleric deals with the divine and the dead. Every class has things that they shine at. Present an opportunity that plays to what one class shines at. It doesn't have to be a class that's in play right now though. Sometimes a locked door stands between you and treasure and there's no thief in sight. This is an invitation for invention, bargaining, and creativity. If all you've got is a bloody axe doesn't every problem look like a skull? ####Show a downside to their class, race, or equipment Just as every class shines, they all have their weaknesses too. Do orcs have a special thirst for elven blood? Is the cleric's magic disturbing dangerous forces? The torch that lights the way also draws attention from eyes in the dark. ####Offer an opportunity, with or without cost Show them something they want: riches, power, glory. If you want, you can associate some cost with it too, of course. Remember to lead with the fiction. You don't say, "This area isn't dangerous so you can make camp here, if you're willing to take the time." You make it a solid fictional thing and say, "Helferth's blessings still hang around the shattered altar. It's a nice safe spot, but the chanting from the ritual chamber is getting louder. What do you do?" ####Put someone in a spot A spot is someplace where a character needs to make tough choices. Put them, or something they care about, in the path of destruction. The harder the choice, the tougher the spot. ####Tell them the requirements or consequences and ask This move is particularly good when they want something that's not covered by a move, or they've failed a move. They can do it, sure, but they'll have to pay the price. Or, they can do it, but there will be consequences. Maybe they can swim through the shark-infested moat before being devoured, but they'll need a distraction. Of course, this is made clear to the characters, not just the players: the sharks are in a starved frenzy, for example. ##Appendix B: Example Keys ###The Shadow of Yesterday Keys: Key of Bloodlust: Hit your key when you overcome an opponent in battle. Buyoff: Pass up an opportunity for a good fight. Key of Conscience: Hit your key when you help someone in trouble or improve someone's life with your compassion. Buyoff: Ignore a cry for help. Key of the Coward: Hit your key when you avoid danger, or stop a battle by means other than violence. Buyoff: Embrace combat. Key of Faith: Hit your key when you defend your faith or convert another to your faith. Buyoff: Renounce your beliefs. Key of Fraternity: Hit your key when you are influenced by your friend, or show how deep your bond is. Buyoff: Sever the relationship with this person. Key of Glittering Gold: Hit your key whenever you increase your wealth. Buyoff: Give away everything you own except what you can carry lightly. Key of the Guardian: Hit your key when you are influenced by your ward, or show how deep your bond is. Buyoff: Sever the relationship with this person. Key of the Impostor: Hit your key when you actively fool someone with your imposture. Buyoff: Reveal your true identity to someone you deceived. Key of the Masochist: Hit your key whenever you are injured, physically or emotionally. Buyoff: Flee a source of physical or emotional injury. Key of the Mission: Hit your key when you take action to complete your mission. Buyoff: Give up on your mission. Key of the Outcast: Hit your key when the fact that you are an outcast is highlighted in the scene in some manner. Buyoff: Regain your former standing or join a new group. Key of Renown: Hit your key whenever you add to your reputation, by words or by deeds. Buyoff: Give someone else credit for an action that would increase your renown. Key of Power: Hit your key whenever you gain power or status, either by improving your own situation or weakening a rival's. Buyoff: Relinquish your power and position. Key of Vengeance. Hit your key when you strike a blow against those who wronged you. Buyoff: Forgive those who wronged you. Key of the Vow: Hit your key when your vow significantly impacts your decisions. Buyoff: Break your vow. ###Lady Blackbird Keys: Key of the Paragon: Hit your key when you demonstrate your superiority or when your noble traits overcome a problem. Buyoff: Disown your noble heritage. Key of the Commander: Hit your key when your orders are obeyed. Buyoff: Acknowledge someone else as the leader. Key of Hidden Longing: Hit your key when you make a decision based on your secret affection or when you somehow show it indirectly. Buyoff: Give up on your secret desire or make it public. Key of Greed: Hit your key when you steal something cool or score a big payoff. Buyoff: Swear off stealing forever. Key of the Daredevil: Hit your key when you do something cool that is risky or reckless (especially piloting stunts). Buyoff: Be very very careful. Key of Banter: Hit your key when your character says something that makes the other players laugh or when you explain something using highly technical jargon. Buyoff: Everyone groans at one of your comments. Key of the Traveler Hit your key when you share an interesting detail about a person, place, or thing or when you go somewhere exciting and new. Buyoff: Pass up the opportunity to see something new. Key of the Broker: Hit your key when you bargain, make a new contact, or exchange a favour. Buyoff: Cut yourself off from your network of contacts. Key of the Tinkerer: Hit your key when you repair, design, or modify technology. Buyoff: Personally destroy a unique or particularly important machine. Key of the Pirate: Hit your key when you impress someone with your piratical capers or add to your notorious reputation. Buyoff: Turn over a new leaf and go straight. ###Dungeon World Alignment Keys: Key of the Chaotic Barbarian: Eschew a convention of the civilized world. Buyoff: Embrace civilization. Key of the Neutral Barbarian: Teach someone the ways of your people. Buyoff: Renounce the ways of your people. Key of the Good Bard: Perform your art to aid someone else. Buyoff: Renounce your art. Key of the Neutral Bard: Avoid a conflict or defuse a tense situation. Buyoff: Throw yourself into battle with no hesitation. Key of the Chaotic Bard: Spur others to significant and unplanned decisive action. Buyoff: Prevent others from acting rashly. Key of the Good Cleric: Heal another. Buyoff: Withhold healing from one who needs it. Key of the Lawful Cleric: Follow the precepts of your church or god. Buyoff: Break the rules of your church of god. Key of the Evil Cleric: Harm another to prove the superiority of your church or god. Buyoff: Denounce your church or god Key of the Chaotic Druid: Destroy a symbol of civilization. Buyoff: Embrace civilization Key of the Good Druid: Help something or someone grow. Buyoff: Destroy something or someone or stunt their growth. Key of the Neutral Druid: Eliminate an unnatural menace. Buyoff: Take no action against an unnatural menace, or even act to support it. Key of the Good Fighter: Defend those weaker than you. Buyoff: Ignore a cry for help Key of the Neutral Fighter: Defeat an opponent. Buyoff: Be defeated in battle. Key of the Evil Fighter: Kill a defenseless, beaten, or surrendered person. Buyoff: Defend someone weaker than you. Key of the Lawful Paladin: Deny mercy to a criminal or unbeliever. Buyoff: Show mercy to a criminal or unbeliever. Key of the Good Paladin: Protect someone weaker than you. Buyoff: Allow someone weaker than you to deal with the danger. Key of the Chaotic Ranger: Free someone from literal or figurative bonds. Buyoff: Restrict somebody else's freedom. Key of the Good Ranger: Combat an unnatural threat. Buyoff: Take no action against an unnatural threat, or even act to support it. Key of the Neutral Ranger: Help an animal or spirit of the wild. Buyoff: Ignore an animal's or spirit's call for help. Key of the Chaotic Thief: Leap into danger without a plan. Buyoff: Methodically plan your actions before taking them. Key of the Neutral Thief: Avoid detection or infiltrate a location. Buyoff: Draw attention to yourself, making stealth impossible. Key of the Evil Thief: Shift danger or blame from yourself to someone else. Buyoff: Accept the blame or take on the danger yourself. Key of the Good Wizard: Use magic to directly aid another. Buyoff: Refuse to magically assist another who could use your help. Key of the Neutral Wizard: Discover something about a magical mystery. Buyoff: Pass up an opportunity to learn more about a magical mystery. Key of the Evil Wizard: Use magic to cause terror and fear. Buyoff: Sincerely attempt to make amends for your previous behavior.